STUPID BOY!!
posted by:
Vicki & Joel
offline Vicki & Joel
20 friends
join to post
  • Tim
    Tim
    offline 45

    Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

    Thu, May 8, 2008 - 8:22 PM
    James is truely no longer the dumbest player to ever play survivor
    join to post
    • Dianne☼
      Dianne☼
      offline 43

      Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

      Thu, May 8, 2008 - 8:25 PM
      You don't think he just threw in the towel? Seems he didn't have a chance in hell to win after trying to get in alliance with everyone left. They were doing a good acting job at tribal council. I really don't know who I want to win, don't like who is really left-maybe Cirie.
      join to post
      • Vick...
        Vicki & Joel
        offline 20

        Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

        Thu, May 8, 2008 - 8:32 PM
        No, I do NOT think he threw in the towel, he fell for their manipulation and scheming, hook - line-and-sinker!

        My husband was calling them bitches, but I say they were SMART and he was just stupid. They planned out exactly what to say and who was going to say it, and exactly how to behave in tribal council, and then they followed their plan to a T. And he was dumb enough to play into it!

        He's a cute kid, but he showed that he didn't deserve the million. Ice cream "man" indeed ;)

        I want Cerie to win, but I fear that Amanda and Parv will be the final 2 unless Natalie wins immunity.
        join to post

  • Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

    Thu, May 8, 2008 - 9:11 PM
    ... wow - I never thought I'd actually see a poor guy get THAT twisted around by those gals.

    Just so young... so stupid...

    I originally thought Jeff was talking about either Ozzie or Jason's non-play of the Hidden Immunity Idol as the "even stupider than James' move last season" thing... but nope - guess this was it.

    OMG - I'd be ashamed to show my face at the reunion show after getting played like that.

    ... heck, I'm ashamed to have the same name as that poor schlub.
    join to post

  • Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

    Thu, May 8, 2008 - 9:28 PM
    That was perhaps the best outwitting I have ever seen on Survivor. It was incredible to watch. Even Natalie didn't think it could be done when Cerie presented the idea to her. Cerie is a genius. They all were incredible in carrying out the plan. Cerie really deserves to win more than ever, now. But Amanda is still my favorite and I'd really like her to win.

    How many of you knew any of those answers in the reward challenge? I've watched every season but they all sort of blur together now. I couldn't remember which season hardly any of those things happened, although I remembered many of those things had happened. The only one I got right was Survivor Outback when someone had fallen in the fire and had to be evacuated. I could remember clearly the Survivor when 4 teams started out instead of 2, but I couldn't remember which location it was in, for instance. Would you all have been able to answer those? You have to hand it to Erik for getting so many right. He is a true fan, and with a good memory. Too bad for him he is so gullible. But the women were brilliant in their strategy. And he's a good sport, too, he was laughing at himself, not angry with the women, it seemed, in the closing comments.
    join to post

    • Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

      Fri, May 9, 2008 - 5:28 AM
      This is where you really know the game is not a physical contest! Poor Eric was such a scmuck! I can't wait to see what happens at Ponderosa! I want Cerie to go all the way now.
      join to post

      • Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

        Fri, May 9, 2008 - 7:30 AM
        Cerie deserves the win for masterminding that plan!

        Wow!!!! is all I can say right now.
        join to post
        • Arin
          Arin
          offline 28

          Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

          Fri, May 9, 2008 - 8:48 AM
          WOWSAS WOWSAS WOWSAS! When Natalie said she felt stupid just hearing the plan, I was laughing. How in the world could you fall for that? It seemed inconceivable. But Cerie, mastermind, developed it beautifully and the rest executed it perfectly. Nonetheless, how could you fall for that plan?

          What is most stupid imo is Erik allowed himself to be convinced he didn't stand a shot with the jury. I disagree. If he makes it as the lone fan and lone male to the final tribal, he has a tailor made argument of how he bucked the odds. Sure, he lied a little bit, but when you are clearly isolated by both your gender and designation (fan) like he is, you do what you need to to get by and ultimately he made it here. I am pretty sure Chris from Vanautu won based on some similar reasoning. I think some of the jury members would've voted for Erik: maybe Jason, maybe Alexis, maybe Natalie, maybe even Oz who adopted him.

          I kinda felt bad for him too, but he got outwitted hard. Loved hearing James proclaim he was no longer the dumbest player in Survivor history. And to whomever said they felt embarassed by their gender and maybe a woman should be running the country, welcome aboard. We woman have known this for a long time. :)
          join to post

          • Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

            Fri, May 9, 2008 - 8:58 AM
            I have to agree. I believe that Cerie should take it all. She has outwitted all of them. Based solely on game play, she is clearly the winner. She really knows how to work people. If Fake Booby Skeletor Chickie doesn't see that she's next, she's a fool.

            I have to say, this is the liveliest jury yet. Eliza's expressions alone are worth it, and he way they all exploded in laughter when Erik gave Natalie the necklace? Priceless...
            join to post
  • Tara
    Tara
    offline 67

    Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

    Fri, May 9, 2008 - 9:21 AM
    what I still dont understand is why anyone would want to go up against Amanda in the final 3. I think Cirie should have gotten Natalie and Eric on her side to go to the end.
    Poor Eric, so young and naive, even after seeing what happened to Ozzy and Jason.
    I think Eric would have had votes on the jury. Probably Eliza and Jason. Maybe Ozzy if Amanda wasnt there. Possibly James and Alexis. He was too awestruck by the famous and sexy Survivor Ladies. LOL.
    join to post
    • Rob(e)
      Rob(e)
      offline 25

      Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

      Fri, May 9, 2008 - 9:36 AM
      I just don't feel sorry for Erik at all. He puts these people up on pedistals like some twisted stalker! "I mean, here are my hero's and they're actually talking to me like I was a real person.." I'm paraphrasing, but that's pretty damn close to what he said in his closing statements! What a TOOL!!! Dude, they're not even CELEBRITIES!!! They're Survivor favorites WHO DIDN'T EVEN WIN!!! He was never going to win because of THAT attitude. I never thought it was cute, but more pathetic. They're human beings brotha....and it cost you in the end.

      Cerie is an evil genius! Way to go girl! She has sooooo many oustings now to her credit it's not even funny. And, the real beauty is that no one even knows it was her that masterminded it. She's like BEN from Lost. She truly is one of THE BEST social players I've ever seen. She reminds me of my sister. Both not physically threatening but mentally they can manipulate and strategize with the best of em. As long as you have the mind frame that this is just a game, but a game for a million dollars, you can go FAR! Props to Cerie....

      Amanda, here you go again. It looks like you could easily take this thing because you are "liked" by everyone, but you won't win because your poutty eyes and lack of closing arguments will be squashed by Cerie! This is where Cerie will shine....That is, assuming that Cerie and Amanda make it to the Finals.

      Is it going to be 3 in the finals again this year? Or 2?
      join to post
      • Kimowan
        Kimowan
        online 106

        Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

        Fri, May 9, 2008 - 9:50 AM
        Wow. I'm scared of girls now. That was in-cred-i-ble. What did James say? Based on the ambiguous editing, I think Poverty might have found the HII.
        join to post

        • Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

          Fri, May 9, 2008 - 10:04 AM
          Cerie can take it against anyone. Who can argue that she didn't play perhaps the best game in Survivor history! Sha can beat Amanda. She just has to get to the final vote. I hope they don't decide to take Booby-Skeletor so they can beat her. I'd hate to see her win anything!
          join to post
          • Tim
            Tim
            offline 45

            Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

            Fri, May 9, 2008 - 11:10 AM
            Well it's hard to say who would win with Nat in the mix .. If she was to fin the final immunity challenge and it is just a final 3 again this year she could win..
            If that happens Cerie would have no choice but to vote for a tie.... If Amanda is dead set on taking Parv to the finals with her then Amanda's only choice would be to vote Cerie and Parv would also.. So in the end it would come down to who Nat would want to be in the finals with.. Vote with Parv and Amanda and risk going against them in the final 3 or vote with Cerie force a tie and hope it all goes well..

            All depends on what the jury is thinking... Will they hold grudges or will they vote for someone who was smart enough to vote them out?
            join to post
            • Arin
              Arin
              offline 28

              Re: *SPOILER* All I have to say about tonight's show is:

              Fri, May 9, 2008 - 11:51 AM
              I'd be extremely shocked at this point if anyone but Amanda or Cerie wins. Something completely odd will have to happen. Obviously one of them will be in the final 3. We've got "I haven't screwed anyone over" Amanda who executed the excellent HII blindside and the "I am the mastermind of this entire game" Cerie. I don't see how either Parv or Nat can compete with that.

              Clearly, Amanda and Cerie need to turn against each other right now. The one who can get it done should win the game. Cerie's problem...as Tim pointed out...Parv appears completely loyal to Amanda and I think if Parv knows she is gonna come in 2nd against someone, she'd rather it be Amanda than Cerie. Also, Amanda is more likely to win final immunity. Amanda's problem....Cerie is the mastermind...if anyone can pull off such a coup against her at this point, it would be Cerie.

              I don't see anyway Nat wins. In addition to being a bitch who has lied to and backstabbed people on the jury, the jury is made up of primarily favorites (Oz, James, Eliza, and for Nat to be in final 3....one of Amanda, Parv or Cerie). Parv has alienated quite a few people as well. Interestingly, if you watch Erik's Ponderosa homecoming, Oz tells him that if it was Erik, Nat and Cerie in final 3, he would've vote for Erik. I was surprised he said Cerie and not Parv since Jason told Oz that Parv was the mastermind of his ouster. Of course, he might have since gotten more accurate information from his second girlfriend Alexis. James wouldn't have known since he wasn't in on it.
              join to post

Recent topics in "Survivor Or Bust"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Casting Calls for Survivor in July 0 June 27, 2008
Problems in Gabon Arin 4 June 11, 2008
Luxury items 4 June 8, 2008
Castaways of the early Survivor episodes 5 June 7, 2008